Christian Construction is one of the few contractors willing to take on projects both small and large. You can call us for something small, like a minor repair or gutter cleaning, or you can contact us to completely rebuild your property from the ground up.
In some cases, this might mean that you have an opportunity to choose how you’re going to heat and power your home. Maybe you’ve always had gas. Maybe you’ve had electric. Maybe you’ve had a combination of both. This may be your opportunity to think about which one you want more.
Both are advantageous. Obviously, electricity is a requirement in every home, regardless of whether you use gas. But should it be what heats your home? Should it be what cooks your food? Let’s compare and contrast each option.
Primary Differences Between Gas and Electric in NYC
Gas and electricity are used to power many of the same household systems – heating, water heaters, cooking appliances, dryers, and more – but they function very differently.
Gas typically refers to natural gas, which is delivered through underground pipelines and burned to produce heat. Electricity, on the other hand, is generated from a range of sources and used to power resistive or inductive systems, often with fewer combustion-related components. The choice between gas and electric power depends on several factors, such as:
Energy Efficiency
Electric systems (especially for heating and hot water) are typically more energy-efficient at the point of use. Modern electric heat pumps and induction cooktops use less energy and waste less heat than older systems.
Gas systems tend to lose some efficiency through heat escape or venting, especially in older furnaces or water heaters. However, some high-efficiency gas appliances narrow this gap considerably.
Upfront and Operating Costs
Gas appliances often have a higher initial installation cost – especially if gas lines need to be installed – but may have lower monthly operating costs, depending on local fuel prices.
Electric systems generally have lower upfront costs and are easier to install, especially in homes that are already wired for electric appliances. However, electricity may cost more per unit depending on usage patterns.
Appliance Performance
Gas stoves and dryers provide faster, more precise heat and are often preferred for specific types of cooking or drying tasks.
Electric appliances offer more consistent heat distribution and are often considered safer for indoor use due to the absence of combustion.
Maintenance and Lifespan
Electric systems generally require less maintenance and have fewer components that wear out over time.
Gas systems may require periodic inspection of burners, vents, and ignition systems, especially for safety and efficiency. If you’re building a property that might fit 3 households or more, then you’re also going to need to consider the time and costs of an LL 152 inspection, which is required New York City for any multifamily property with a gas line – even if its only used for one small purpose.
Safety Considerations
Electric systems reduce the risk of gas leaks, carbon monoxide exposure, and combustion-related fires.
Gas systems are safe when properly installed and maintained, but require ventilation and carbon monoxide detection as a precaution.
Environmental Impact
Electric systems have the potential to be powered by renewable sources like solar, wind, or hydroelectric energy, making them more environmentally sustainable—especially if your utility offers green power options.
Natural gas is a fossil fuel. While it emits less carbon dioxide than coal or oil, it still contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.
These are all the primary differences between gas an electric.
When Gas May Be a Better Option
There are many situations where a gas line is preferred. These include, but are not limited to:
- You already have a gas line installed and want to reduce electricity bills
- You prefer faster heat for cooking or clothes drying
- You live in an area where natural gas is significantly less expensive than electricity
- You are installing a backup generator system that uses natural gas
In these situations, gas is going to be your preferred option.
When Electricity May Be a Better Option
On the other hand, you may want to consider electricity if gas is not calling to you. Electrical heating and energy often provides benefits that include
- You’re looking to reduce your home’s carbon footprint
- You live in an all-electric home or area without gas infrastructure
- You want to pair your appliances with solar or other renewable energy systems
- You prefer low-maintenance systems and enhanced indoor safety
Some homeowners opt for a hybrid or dual-fuel approach, combining gas and electric systems for optimal performance. For example, a gas furnace might be paired with an electric heat pump, switching based on outdoor temperatures and efficiency. This approach can balance energy costs, performance, and sustainability.
Choosing the Option That’s Right for You
Choosing between gas and electricity isn’t always a matter of which is “better.” it’s about which is most practical, cost-effective, and aligned with your household needs.
Before making any major decisions, consider:
- Current utility rates in your area
- Your home’s existing infrastructure
- Your budget for installation and maintenance
- Environmental priorities and long-term energy goals
At Christian Construction, we’re happy to do our best to talk to you about these different options and help decide which one is best for you. For more information, or to get started, please reach out to us today.
